diff --git a/library/ZendAfi/Validate/ProfilRewriteUrl.php b/library/ZendAfi/Validate/ProfilRewriteUrl.php
index b6d5f3716440587737ecff1a0ff2cb15eea20312..7055e4d79544975fe9e8c12689e57934a37fdf99 100644
--- a/library/ZendAfi/Validate/ProfilRewriteUrl.php
+++ b/library/ZendAfi/Validate/ProfilRewriteUrl.php
@@ -87,9 +87,9 @@ class ZendAfi_Validate_ProfilRewriteUrl extends Zend_Validate_Abstract {
 		$profils = array_filter($profils,
 														function ($model) use ($page) {
 																return $model->hasParentProfil()
-																	&& ($model->getParent()->getRewriteUrl())
 																  && ($model->getId() !== $page->getId())
-																	&& ($model->getParent()->getRewriteUrl() == $page->getParent()->getRewriteUrl());});
+																	&& ($model->getParent()->getRewriteUrl() == $page->getParent()->getRewriteUrl());
+														});
 
 		if (count($profils)==0)
 			return true;
diff --git a/tests/library/Class/ProfilTest.php b/tests/library/Class/ProfilTest.php
index 319930150f73db1fae72301f06ea6018d6ad828b..b06a658c0f6613afee6877b81dc411d9db0e5d5a 100644
--- a/tests/library/Class/ProfilTest.php
+++ b/tests/library/Class/ProfilTest.php
@@ -749,6 +749,7 @@ class ProfilAdulteChatenayTest extends ProfilAdulteChatenayTestCase  {
 												implode(',', $this->profil->getErrors()));
 	}
 
+
 	/** @test */
 	public function pageWithParentProfilWithoutRewriteUrlShouldBeValid() {
 		$this->page_nature = Class_Profil::newInstance([
@@ -760,6 +761,28 @@ class ProfilAdulteChatenayTest extends ProfilAdulteChatenayTestCase  {
 	}
 
 
+
+	/** @test */
+	public function twoPagesWithParentProfilWithoutRewriteUrlAndSameUrlShouldNotBeValid() {
+		$this->fixture('Class_Profil', ['id' => 345,
+																		'parent_id' => null,
+																		'libelle' => 'one profile',
+																		'rewrite_url' => '']);
+
+		$this->fixture('Class_Profil', ['id' => 543,
+																		'parent_id' => 1,
+																		'libelle' => 'Nature',
+																		'rewrite_url' => 'nature']);
+
+		$page_nature = Class_Profil::newInstance([
+																							'parent_id' => 1,
+																							'libelle' => 'Nature',
+																							'rewrite_url' => 'nature']);
+
+		$this->assertFalse($page_nature->isValid());
+	}
+
+
 	/** @test */
 	public function pageWithParentProfilWithSameRewriteUrlAsAnotherProfilShouldBeValid() {
 		$this->profil_nature = $this->fixture('Class_Profil',